Best Pizza Pans

Are you tired of ordering takeout every time you crave a delicious pizza? Why not try making your own homemade pie with a crispy crust? The key to achieving the perfect pizza lies in having the right equipment, such as a pizza stone or steel. These tools are essential for creating a pizza with a professional touch, crispiness, and even cooking.

There are various materials to choose from when it comes to pizza stones, including clay, cast iron, ceramic, or cordierite. Pizza steels, on the other hand, are typically made from steel and offer faster cooking time. It’s important to select a recipe that complements your chosen pizza stone or steel to ensure the best results.

Key Takeaways

  • Investing in a high-quality pizza stone or steel is essential for achieving a crispy crust.
  • There are various materials available for pizza stones, each with its own advantages.
  • Pizza steels heat up faster and cook more quickly than pizza stones.
  • Choosing the right recipe is crucial for successful pizza making with a stone or steel.
  • Using additional tools like a pizza paddle, cutter, and infrared thermometer can enhance the pizza-making experience.

Our Top Pizza Stone and Steel Picks

When it comes to achieving that perfect crispy crust for your homemade pizza, having the right pizza stone or steel is essential. We’ve researched and tested a variety of options to bring you our top picks for pizza stones and steels. Whether you prefer the classic taste of a pizza stone or the rapid cooking power of a pizza steel, we’ve got you covered.

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan

Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan

  • Hailed as the best overall option
  • Constructed from durable cast iron for excellent heat retention and distribution
  • Pre-seasoned surface for easy release and enhanced flavor

The Original Baking Steel

The Original Baking Steel

  • Top choice for pizza steel
  • Made from premium steel for rapid and even cooking
  • Generous surface area accommodates large pizzas

Emile Henry French Ceramic Pizza Stone

Emile Henry French Ceramic Pizza Stone

  • Best ceramic option
  • High-quality construction ensures excellent heat distribution
  • Crafted in France for authentic pizza baking experience

Cuisinart Three-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

Cuisinart Three-Piece Pizza Grilling Set

  • Perfect for those who want a complete pizza stone set
  • Includes a pizza stone, pizza peel, and pizza cutter
  • Grilling set allows for versatile outdoor pizza baking

Unicook Heavy Duty Corderite Pizza Stone

Unicook Heavy Duty Corderite Pizza Stone

  • Best budget buy
  • Made from durable corderite for excellent heat retention
  • Provides a crisp and evenly cooked crust every time

With these top-rated pizza stones and steels, you can take your homemade pizza game to the next level. Choose the option that best suits your cooking style and preferences, and enjoy delicious, crispy pizzas in the comfort of your own home.

The Difference Between a Pizza Stone and Steel

When it comes to achieving that perfect crispy crust for your homemade pizza, choosing the right cooking surface is key. There are two popular options to consider: pizza stones and pizza steels. While they both serve the same purpose, there are significant differences between the two.

Pizza Stones

Pizza stones are commonly made from materials such as clay, cast iron, ceramic, or cordierite. These materials have excellent heat conductivity, meaning they distribute heat evenly across the surface of the stone. This even heat distribution helps to bake the pizza thoroughly, resulting in a deliciously cooked crust.

However, one downside of pizza stones is that they take slightly longer to heat up compared to pizza steels. But once heated, they provide consistent heat, maintaining the ideal cooking temperature throughout the baking process.

Pizza Steels

In contrast, pizza steels are made from steel, which is known for its high heat conductivity. This means that pizza steels heat up much faster than pizza stones, allowing for quicker cooking times.

Additionally, pizza steels are less prone to cracking or shattering due to thermal shock. This durability makes them a long-lasting option for your pizza-baking needs.

However, it’s important to note that while pizza steels heat up quickly, they may not distribute heat as evenly as pizza stones. This can result in variations in cooking across the surface of the pizza.

Factors Pizza Stones Pizza Steels
Material Composition Clay, cast iron, ceramic, or cordierite Steel
Heat Conductivity Even heat distribution for consistent cooking High heat conductivity for faster cooking
Thermal Shock Resistance May crack or shatter with sudden temperature changes Durable and less prone to cracking or shattering

Ultimately, the choice between a pizza stone and a pizza steel depends on your preference for cooking time, heat distribution, and durability. Both options can help you achieve that mouthwatering homemade pizza with a perfectly crispy crust. Choose the one that aligns with your cooking style and enjoy the delicious results.

How to Use Pizza Stones and Steels

When it comes to using pizza stones and steels, there are a few key things to keep in mind to achieve the best results. By following these tips, you can ensure that your pizza cooks evenly and comes out perfectly crispy.

  1. Avoid stacking: It’s important not to stack multiple pizza stones or steels on top of each other in the oven. This can prevent proper heat distribution and lead to uneven cooking. Place your stone or steel directly on the oven rack for best results.
  2. Perfect placement: For optimal cooking, position your pizza stone or steel on the middle rack of the oven. This allows for even heat distribution and helps to create a consistent crust. However, if you have a small oven or are baking for a large group, you may need to adjust the placement slightly.
  3. Transferring the pizza: Once your pizza is cooked to perfection, it’s time to remove it from the oven. To protect your pizza stone or steel, carefully transfer the pizza to a cutting board or a knife-friendly serving platter. This will prevent scratching or damaging the surface of your cooking tool.

By following these simple guidelines, you can make the most out of your pizza stone or steel and enjoy delicious homemade pizza with a perfectly crispy crust.

Expert Tip: Preheating your pizza stone or steel

To achieve the best results, preheat your pizza stone or steel in the oven before placing your pizza on it. This helps to ensure that the cooking surface is hot enough to create that crispy crust. Preheat your stone or steel for about 30 minutes at the desired cooking temperature before you start baking your pizza.

Advantages of Pizza Stones Advantages of Pizza Steels
– Provide more even cooking – Heat up faster
– Can be made from different materials – Cook pizza more quickly
– Help achieve a crispy crust – Less prone to cracking or shattering

Choosing the Right Recipe for Your Pizza Stone

The recipe you choose plays a crucial role in the performance of your pizza stone or steel. To achieve the best results, it’s important to start with a solid pizza recipe that complements your chosen cooking surface. A classic Pizza Margherita, for example, can be an excellent choice.

When selecting your ingredients, opt for high-quality items that will enhance the flavors of your pizza. Fresh mozzarella, with its creamy texture and subtle tang, is a popular choice. Accompany it with a traditional Neapolitan crust, known for its thin and crispy texture. Don’t forget to add some fragrant basil leaves and a delicious tomato puree for that authentic Italian taste.

Another important consideration when working with your pizza stone or steel is the temperature of your dough. Using room temperature dough is recommended as cold temperatures can limit yeast activity and affect the rise of your crust.

To ensure that your dough doesn’t stick to your work surface, try using a 1:1 mixture of cornmeal and flour. Sprinkle it on your work surface before shaping your pizza dough. This will create a non-stick surface and add a delightful texture to the bottom of your crust.

When it’s time to transfer your pizza to the oven, using a pizza paddle lined with the same cornmeal and flour mixture can make the process smoother. The pizza will easily slide off the paddle onto the hot surface of your stone or steel.

Remember, the right recipe and technique, combined with the perfect ingredients, will help you achieve professional-quality pizza at home.

Other Tools You Need to Make Pizza At Home

In addition to a pizza stone or steel, there are other tools that can enhance your at-home pizza making experience. Let’s take a look at some essential tools:

Pizza Paddle

A pizza paddle, also known as a pizza peel, is a must-have tool for transferring your pizza into the oven and removing it when it’s done. It is a long-handled flat wooden or metal board with a flat surface, providing support and stability for your pizza while ensuring a smooth transition between the prep area and the oven.

Pizza Cutter or Wheel

Once your delicious pizza is out of the oven, you’ll need a pizza cutter or wheel to slice it into perfect portions. A sharp and sturdy pizza cutter glides effortlessly through the crispy crust, ensuring clean cuts and preserving the integrity of your toppings.

Infrared Thermometer

For the best results, it’s important to monitor the temperature of your baking surface and oven accurately. An infrared thermometer is a handy tool that allows you to measure the temperature without direct contact. By aiming the infrared sensor at the surface, you can quickly determine if it has reached the desired temperature for baking your pizza.

Baking Surface Temperature

Knowing the temperature of your baking surface is crucial for achieving the perfect crust. Different recipes and pizza stones or steels require specific temperatures for optimal results. Use an instant-read thermometer to monitor and adjust the baking surface temperature, ensuring that it’s at the ideal level for a crispy and evenly cooked pizza.

These additional tools, along with a high-quality pizza stone or steel, will elevate your homemade pizza-making experience and help you create delicious, professional-style pizzas in the comfort of your own home.

Tool Description
Pizza Paddle A long-handled board used for transferring pizzas in and out of the oven.
Pizza Cutter or Wheel A sharp cutting tool designed specifically for slicing pizzas.
Infrared Thermometer A device that measures temperature without direct contact, ideal for checking baking surface and oven temperatures.
Baking Surface Temperature An instant-read thermometer to ensure the baking surface reaches the desired temperature for the perfect crust.

How We Tested the Pizza Stones and Steels

Our team conducted a rigorous testing process to evaluate the performance of different pizza stones and steels. We wanted to ensure that we recommended products that would deliver exceptional results in terms of temperature retention, heat distribution, and overall pizza quality.

We began by baking pizzas on each pizza stone and steel at the same oven temperature. This allowed us to compare how well each product retained heat and reached the ideal baking temperature for even cooking.

To evaluate the quality of the pizzas, we paid close attention to achieving a golden crust with an evenly cooked interior. We examined factors such as cheese melting and bubbling, as well as the overall taste and texture of the pizza.

Our goal was to identify pizza stones and steels that not only heated up quickly and distributed heat evenly but also produced pizzas that met our high standards of quality.

By conducting thorough testing and considering factors such as temperature retention, heat distribution, and pizza quality, we were able to confidently select the best pizza stones and steels for our recommendations.


In conclusion, if you’re looking to achieve a crispy crust and enjoy delicious homemade pizza, investing in a high-quality pizza stone or steel is essential. Our top picks include the Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Baking Pan, The Original Baking Steel, Emile Henry French Ceramic Pizza Stone, Cuisinart Three-Piece Pizza Grilling Set, and Unicook Heavy Duty Corderite Pizza Stone. These top-rated options will help you create professional-quality pizzas in the comfort of your own home.

Whether you prefer the versatility of a pizza stone or the faster cooking time of a pizza steel, these tools are designed to enhance your pizza-making experience. They provide even heat distribution, ensuring that your pizzas are cooked to perfection every time. With these pizza pans, you’ll be able to achieve that crispy crust you’ve always desired.

So, grab your favorite pizza recipe and get ready to bring the pizzeria experience straight to your kitchen. With the help of these top-rated pizza pans, you’ll be able to bake the best homemade pies and impress your family and friends with your culinary skills. Say goodbye to mediocre delivery pizzas and hello to the satisfaction of savoring a homemade pizza with a crispy crust that rivals your favorite pizzerias.

Scroll to Top